Tapping vs. Talk Therapy: What's the Difference?

Have you ever known something in your head, but your body didn't seem to believe it? People pleasing is a good example.

Consciously, you know you don't have to please people. You know you'll survive if they aren't happy with your choices.

And yet you can't shake the feeling. When a choice might make someone angry or earn you disapproval, the anxiety shows up anyway.

You understand it. You could probably explain it clearly. But your body still reacts as if someone's anger or disapproval might be the death of you.

I recently listened to the Integrated Tapping Summit, hosted by Gene Monterastelli. Gene asked one question and heard the answer from many different perspectives: "What is something that tapping on an emotional issue does that simply talking about that emotional issue does not?"

Here's what I took away about how tapping is different from talk therapy, and how I see it play out in my work.

First, talk therapy is valuable. Julie Shiffman reminded us that talking brings insight, connections, a chance to vent, and an understanding of where our thoughts, feelings and behaviours come from. This isn't about one being better than the other. They do different jobs.

Andy Hunt explained that talking happens from a step back. He pointed to one small word: "about." To talk or think about something, you have to step out of it and look at it from a distance.

That distance gives us insight and meaning. But it also takes us away from the feeling itself.

Many of us are very good at thinking our way out of a feeling and putting a "cognitive lid" on it. That works most of the time. But, as Andy says, it leaks.

Tapping keeps you in contact with the feeling.

An emotion is really a felt experience in the body, like butterflies before an interview, tightness in the chest, or heat in the face. The word we give the emotion is just a cognitive label.

Kristin Panasewicz put it simply: emotions are sensations. We call them feelings because we feel them.

Mirjam Paninski explained that you can describe fear all day and still stay one step removed from it, because language is how the brain organizes and contains experience. Talking keeps the emotion inside the story about it.

Tapping asks you to stay with what you're feeling in your body while you tap on the points. That combination allows the emotional charge to actually update, instead of being retold over and over.

Tapping speaks to a different part of the brain.

Jennifer Cincurak explained that talking can't reach the deeper, lower layers of the brain directly. These are the parts that run our survival responses, and they don't understand language. That's one reason talk therapy alone tends to take longer. Those deeper layers respond to the senses, movement and imagination, not words alone.

Tapping works through the body, so it speaks to that part of the brain directly. As the body feels safer, the intensity often comes down on its own, and we start to see the situation through a different lens.

Understanding isn't the same as processing.

This is what happens with people pleasing. You can understand exactly why you don't need everyone's approval, and your body still responds with anxiety the next time someone might be upset with you.

Talking helps us understand an emotion. Tapping helps us feel it and move through it.

My favourite image from the summit came from Sejual Shan.

Over a lifetime, a series of events builds a brick wall around us that can trap and limit us. The bricks are the events. The mortar holding them together is emotion.

Talking can give us a clear view of the wall and how it was built. Tapping dissolves the mortar. We still remember what happened, but the wall comes down, and the emotion no longer pens us in.

So what can you do with this?

Next time you notice yourself explaining a feeling to yourself again (going over why it happened, what it means, what you should have done), try this:

Pause and ask, "Where do I feel this in my body?"
Notice the sensation. Is it tight, heavy, hot, fluttery? You don't need to fix it or make it go away.
Gently tap just below your collarbones while you stay with that sensation for a few slow breaths.

You're not talking about the feeling. You're being with it.

As Nancy Forrester shared at the summit, the aim isn't to get rid of the emotion. When we acknowledge it instead of pushing it away, the nervous system has a chance to let it move through.

And if you're already working with a counsellor, this isn't a replacement for that work. Tapping can sit right alongside it, helping your body catch up with what your mind already understands.

If you'd like to explore what tapping could add to the work you're already doing, I offer a free 30-minute discovery call.

Here's to calming stress at the source.

With heart,

Louise

The Stress Experts

Did this blog help you?

Consider sharing it with someone who needs to hear it!

Have a question?

Let me know. I love answering questions! Contact me!